🦘 Math Kangaroo Grade All Felix 1-2 Ecolier 3-4 Benjamin 5-6 Kadett 7-8 Junior 9-10 Student 11-12 ⇄ switch contest
2021 Math Kangaroo

Problem 17

Problem 17 · 2021 Math Kangaroo Medium
Logic & Word Problems casework

Ronja had four white tokens and Wanja had four grey tokens. They played a game in which they took turns to place one of their tokens to create two piles. Ronja placed her first token first. Which pair of piles could they not create?

Figure for Math Kangaroo 2021 Problem 17
Show answer
Answer: E
Show hints
Hint 1 of 2
Tokens are placed alternately starting with a white one, so the placing order constrains each pile.
Still stuck? Show hint 2 →
Hint 2 of 2
Reconstruct the colour pattern each option needs and find the one no legal alternating order can produce.
Show solution
Approach: test each stacking against the alternating rule
  1. Ronja (white) places first, then they alternate colours as they build the two piles.
  2. For each option, try to order the eight placements so colours alternate and the piles end up as shown.
  3. Only the pair in choice E cannot arise from any valid alternating sequence.
Mark: · log in to save